not to be confused with the movie Carnal Knowledge,a product of the ’70’s….
I bought the book for the title. ANYONE who could get away with a title like that is a friend of mine, and I would support that friendship by buying his books. But since the author, Al Sicherman,
is in Minnesota, still working at the Star Tribune we’ve never actually met.
It was in Caramel Knowledge that I first learned of The Theory of Cooking Relativity
But I remembered it wrong. So after I tell you what I actually read, the words that have remained on the pages all these many years, then I will tell you MY theory, with the words that have been in my head (and coming out of my mouth ) for many of these same many years.
It starts with popovers. Al has a a no-fail popover recipe that someone has all sorts of trouble making.
A reader of Al’s, Esme Evans, suggested
“Evans Theory of Relative Competence: Every time you figure out how to cook something new reasonably well, you cease to be able to cook something you had thought you had mastered.” p. 43.
She has examples – fallen cakes after mastering baklava; good pie crust = unable to separate eggs (making a lemon meringue pie becomes a trail….)
There’s a certain amount of sense in this, which is how in my brain I came up with The Theory of Cooking Relativity.
The theory states: Each person has a set point of culinary competence, which varies with each person. Some people can be extremely good at lots of things – think Bobby Flay or Julia Child – this is the high end of the relative scale. There are a few – a very few – who are not very good at most things . You know – the ones who are not up to the challenge of Campbell’s soup.
Most everyone else fall somewhere in the middle. Some people are extremely good at one or two things – signature dishes. Others are relatively good at lots of things – no blue ribbons, but no horror stories. This is where Evans Theory of Relative Competence is most apparent.
What all this means is – there IS a cooking gene, and not everyone has it. Some people are born to cook, and some are born to set the table. What’s important is knowing where you are in the spectrum, and that there IS a spectrum, and we’re not all at the same place.
The band Swing Set just showed up at the Kiskadee Coffee Company…time to stop and smell the coffee – and listen to the jazz.